A
contentious thing to put in your laptop computer. OEMs love them because they look all
futuristic and add an air of mystique to their product. Quite a few users hate them because they make simple mouse tasks a chore to do.
The touchpad
blurb makes a big thing of how you can tap it to simulate a mouse click. Unfortunately you can't push hard to simulate a drag. Some drivers allow you to double-tap to
drag-lock, but then how do you
doubleclick? The most straightforward way is to hold a mouse button and proceed as normal, but for the uncoordinated (or those with poorly positioned buttons) this is a two-hand operation.
Badly positioned touchpads get in the way while
typing. It is possible, especially while
touch-typing to snag the touchpad with the base of either thumb. Moving the pointer around is not a bad thing in itself, but when the pad is set to 'tap to click', this can mean moving the cursor, and an irritated typist.
There is no real middle-ground with regards to sensitivity on most touch-pads. After all, the finger is quite a chubby object. That's why most people
don't write with finger-paint. This makes it quite difficult to position the thing accurately enough to snag small items (such as the
Winamp volume control, or
Netscape's toolbar retract buttons). With the sensitivity way down low, the screen can be upwards of three touchpads long. With a mouse or a
trackstick, you can just move faster (or harder) and use
proportional acceleration. This would just make touchpads even more confusing...
You can't play
Quake with them. At all. Try it. (You can, however, play
Descent with an
Accupoint/trackstick. It's like a tiny analogue
joystick...)
Touchpads mostly benefit the
OEM by being extremely flat. They have a smaller vertical
footprint than an
Accupoint, much smaller than a
trackball. This leaves more space for a circuit board under the
keyboard, or a screen above it. From a
user's point of view, they do look
cooler, and they don't suffer from
Accupoint drift. They don't need new
caps, don't get
grubby, and don't need their rollers cleaned. But you still can't play
quake on them. ;P
Dell has a nice solution in their
Inspiron range where the laptop has two sets of buttons, a trackstick and a touchpad.
Touchpad haters can configure the touchpad to behave like additional mouse buttons;
Trackstick haters can ignore it, or use it as a button.
Clever.
Incedentally, Accupoint is a trademark of Toshiba but it has fallen into common use in the same way as Hoover...