Missouri Compromise

However, when Representative James Tallmadge of New York attempted to add an anti-slavery amendment to the bill, an ugly debate broke out over slavery and the government's right to restrict slavery. The Tallmadge amendment prohibited any additional slaves into Missouri and provided for emancipation of those already there when they reached age 25.

The amendment passed the House of Representatives, which was, at the time, controlled by the more populous North. When the bill reached the Senate however, it failed, since the Senate was equally divided between free and slave states. As it would turn out, the cowards in Congress adjourned before ever really resolving the problem.

When it reconvened in December 1819, Congress had on its table a request for statehood from Maine. As a compromise, the Senate passed a bill allowing Maine to enter the Union as a free state, and Missouri to be admitted without restrictions on slavery. This was not the end of their problems, however.

When the Missouri constitutional convention empowered the state legislature to exclude free blacks, a new crisis was brought on. Enough northern Congressmen objected that the government called upon Mr. Henry Clay to draft the Second Missouri Compromise. On March 2, 1821, Congress stipulated that Missouri could not gain admission to the Union until it agreed that the exclusionary clause would never be interpreted in such a way as to abridge the privileges and immunities of U.S. citizens. Missouri forcefully agreed, and became the 24th state on Aug. 10, 1821; Maine had been admitted the previous March 15.

The compromise measures appeared to settle the slavery-extension issue, however, and the sectional conflict did not grow to the point of civil war until after the Missouri Compromise was repealed by the Kansas-Nebraska Act (1854) and was declared unconstitutional in the Dred Scott decision.

In the early 1800s the northern, or 'free' states, were more populous and industrial than the southern, or 'slave' states. Thus, the U.S. House of Representatives was run primarily by the north. The only thing stopping the north from passing anti-slavery legislation was the Senate. While the north had more people, it still had the same number of states as the south, and just as many senators.

Missouri was going to join the Union as a slave state, tacking on two more votes for southern interests. The north couldn't have that. Allowing a slave state in the western lands and in the area of the Louisiana Purchase was a bad precedent, also it would tip the scales in the Senate toward the south. Neither side wanted a state to be admitted to either side.

In late 1819 and early 1820 there came a solution to the dilemma. Maine, which was previously a part of Massachusetts, was admitted to the Union as a free state, and Missouri was admitted to the Union as a slave state. A pair of states added almost simultaneously worked for both sides of the Mason-Dixon Line. But what about the precedent of slavery in the western lands.

Henry Clay, a northern Senator who sold the idea in Congress, also sold the idea of creating a border between the future slave and future free states. Missouri's southern border, a line along the 36th parallel, was accepted as the border. Future territories above that line were to be free, and below were to be slave.

This Compromise of 1820 was in effect until the 1850 when a new compromise was written and the Dred Scott case was decided.