Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Gilligan's theory of women's moral development

created by snarkyrose

(idea) by snarkyrose (4.8 y) (print)   ?   I like it! Wed Jan 08 2003 at 6:59:16

Carol Gilligan, a student of Lawrence Kohlberg, was taken by the stage theory development approach. However, she disagreed with her mentor's ideas of the content of the moral system within which people developed. When looking at Kohlberg's stages, one can see that the focus is duty, guilt and justice, as if to say, "What are the rules to this game?"

In watching Kohlberg's investigations of women, Gilligan saw that they tended to score repeatedly lower than men. Was this true? Could women really be midgets morally? After interviewing many women making momentous decisions, Gilligan concluded that women were thinking more about the caring thing to do than what was "just and right."

In taking this stand, she was going against popular psychological opinion. Sigmund Freud believed that women's sense of moral development was stunted due to their attachment to their mothers. Erik Erikson, another developmental theorist, saw women as morally deficient unless they could suceed at their separation from mother and family.

In reply, Gilligan asserted that a woman's sense of moral development came from connections to other people, rather than separation of such. Her purpose was to find a second dimension for moral reasoning by showing that previous studies were done predominately with males in mind.

Most psychologists now disagree with the claim that men and women differ in their moral reasoning in the way that Gilligan outlines. Several studies have been done to show that men and women use both justice/reasoning and care in their moral decisions. It is now being studied by careful researches, cleaning up the trail that she blazed.


printable version
chaos

Kohlberg's theory of moral development Anna O. Why feminist ethics is not relativism Erikson's eight stages of psychosocial development
Ted Bundy's defense of moral subjectivism A Response to Michael Levin on Feminist Ethics Punish me with kisses Piaget's Stages of Development
Gilligan's Island Gilligan The "Mary Ann or Ginger?" Game Yossarian's School of Badassary
heteronomous morality wonk Link and Link Erik Erikson
Ken Wilber Sigmund Freud Gilligan's Island rule White Cross Movement
conjunction How to improve your chances of having sex Microsoft Windows Jean Piaget
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Drink up!
Premature infant
Unusual natural phenomena
The Rise of Islam
Frank Zappa: Statement To Congress September 19, 1985
Brainfuck
Teach your million tiny babies to parasail
Dissociative identity disorder
What is conflict, and why bother to resolve it?
Keyboards in a computer lab with very sticky keys that make you
Unification of Italy
An eyewitness account of the Nagasaki bombing
Freedom of religion is not freedom from religion
How Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends wrecked my love life
New Writeups
aneurin
British Monomarks(idea)
FrankThomas
How and why do we (humans) have culture?(essay)
lee_cad
Isaac(person)
kalen
downvota(poetry)
Andrew Aguecheek
Wstfgl(thing)
ncc05
overheard at IHOP(event)
calgon
Bottomless(poetry)
lismaraxt
Ice Theory of The Origin of Life(idea)
allthetime
Apple Cinnamon Suicide(idea)
Lucy-S
shovelglove(idea)
Adaptive Child
Mexican secret sauce(recipe)
Adaptive Child
nacho libre(recipe)
TheLady
Iron Man(review)
Scaevola
Risk in the Roman law of sale(idea)
semicolon
overheard at IHOP(event)
E2 is a by-product of the existence of The Everything Development Company