Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

The real reason pi was never calculated to a high precision in ancient times

created by kslawson

(idea) by Professor Pi (3.2 wk) (print)   ?   2 C!s I like it! Sat Dec 16 2000 at 19:07:16

The real reason that pi was never calculated at high precision is that for day to day applications, ancient cultures didn't need a high precision. Ancient equipment generally had a lower accuracy compared to modern tools. For instance, there is no need to know pi in six decimals, if you can only measure the radius to an accuracy of two decimals.

Even nowadays, there is no practical use for a million digits of pi, simply because we cannot measure anything in the physical world to that accuracy. For instance, one of the most precise measurements possible today relies on the Mössbauer Effect and will yield results accurate to 14 digits. That's an error of one second in 3 million years. Also note that 39 digits of pi suffice to calculate the circumference of the known universe from its radius to within the diameter of the hydrogen atom1.


1: Fractals, Chaos, Power Laws, Minutes from an Infinite Paradise, Manfred Schroeder, New York, W.H. Freeman and Company, 1991


(idea) by Phssthpok (2.6 y) (print)   ?   1 C! I like it! Sat Dec 16 2000 at 22:11:49

Thanks to Professor Pi for explaining that "high precision" actually means only as many digits as can be used. However, the "ancients" calculated far more than they had use for. I've heard stories told about ninety-one-sided polygons inscribed in circles for measuring purposes. Let me say that again: ninety-one sides!!! That is not a sign of being too lazy to write things down.

Now let's take a look at how much accuracy was actually calculated. By using purely arithmetic methods to calculate the continued fraction expansion, pi =


             1
3 + ----------------------
               1
    7 + ------------------
                  1
        15 + -------------
                    1
             1 + ---------
                 292 + ...

Convergent   1      2         3         4           5
Fraction     3     22/7    333/106   355/113  103993/33102
Error      .045   -.0004   .000026   -8.5E-8    1.8E-10

It is clear that an incredibly adequate amount of accuracy becomes available with very little calculation. So, when the Greeks used their calculation of 22/7 as "slightly larger than pi," they had all the accuracy they needed for calculations of the time.


printable version
chaos

Mössbauer Effect Pi in the Bible The lost scene from Austin Powers 2 Taking your fiance's last name
Former teacher sentenced to 12Π years for sexual abuse Oh, did you learn to play chess after YOU dropped a barbell on your head, too? Your radical ideas about roman numerals have already occurred to others Roman numerals
Digits of Pi Memorizing Pi Ad nauseam Rational approximations of common irrational numbers
Elevator algorithm pi π exercise for the reader
Mnemonics for e Mössbauer Spectroscopy continued fraction number theory
vi Slartibartfast xv God made the integers, all else is the work of man
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help


cooled by liveforever

Cool Staff Picks
What you are reading:
Bridgeborough, New Jersey
Do Orthodox Jewish lesbian couples practice "family purity"?
Singing Sand
The problems of the modern west
Somebody Blew Up America
This is Just to Say
Carnal Harvest
XP stoicism
Walter goes down the drain the same way in Australia
Molecular Biology of HIV
A Tail of Two Monkeys
Formatting poems and simple HTML
Kabbalah FAQ
New Writeups
locke baron
Tyan Thunder K8WE(thing)
locke baron
Udaloy class destroyer(thing)
Scaevola
Same-sex marriage(idea)
SteveMurrayFromNZ
British Standard Handful(idea)
nailbiter
nerve stapling(thing)
locke baron
Multiple Myeloma(thing)
SubSane
blonde, freckles, skinny, short(person)
arcanamundi
A Ruba'iyat for May(person)
riverrun
Timed Writing(idea)
auraseer
Fling(fiction)
StrawberryFrog
Iron Man(review)
devolution
Misogyny and Porn, East to West - An Empirical Analysis(idea)
devolution
Korea is a place that refuses to stand still(idea)
Beanie127
The Pacifist Soldier(fiction)
VergilKint
Distilled from Dreams(fiction)
Everything 2 is brought to you by the letter C and The Everything Development Company