Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Neogrammarian

created by Gritchka

(idea) by Gritchka (2.5 y) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 2 C!s Fri May 17 2002 at 12:34:24

A movement among German phoneticians in the 1870s, whose tenet was that all sound changes follow a rule. There are no sporadic exceptions, and every apparent exception to a law of sound change can be explained by finding some other law, or some other good reason why a different form was adopted. This is called the Regularity Principle.

The Neogrammarian hypothesis was controversial in its time, and underwent theoretical challenges over the next half century, but it has long been accepted by almost all linguists. It may therefore be called an axiom not only of phonetics but of linguistics: there is always a good reason for any change, and it can in principle be found.

The original German term is Junggrammatiker. It was, I gather, first applied to the Neogrammarians by their opponents. The principle was explicitly stated by August Leskien in 1876. Another prominent Neogrammarian was Karl Brugmann, and their major text was Hermann Paul's 1880 Prinzipien der Sprachgeschichte (Principles of Language History).

At that time the most impressive example of a sound law was Grimm's Law, which explained the consonants of the primitive Germanic languages in comparison with the consonants of Latin, Greek, and Sanskrit.

The wide application of Grimm's Law to a whole range of consonants was marred by exceptions in a smaller number of words. The Danish linguist Karl Verner put forward an explanation of these in 1876, showing that developments in Germanic went in a different but consistent direction when the accent was on the following syllable.

For example, Grimm's Law predicts the following matches:

Latin   Greek   Sanskrit   Proto-Germanic   Proto-Indo-European
  p       p        p            f                p
  t       t        t            th               t
  f       ph       bh           b                bh
The Proto-Germanic is the reconstructed (not known from writing) ancestor of English, German, Scandinavian, and so on, and the Proto-Indo-European (= PIE) is the reconstructed common ancestor of all four of the others.

So Latin frater, Greek phrater, Sanskrit bhratar, and Germanic brother all match. (The vowels are also related by known laws.) If we just use modern English father, then that too matches Latin pater, Greek pater-, and Sanskrit pitar, but this shows the perils of incomplete data. This would not look like an exception if modern English was all we had. But in Old English it was fader and in German it's Vater (where V = F). These both imply an original Germanic fader, which fails to correspond by Grimm's Law.

However, given that the Proto-Indo-European forms were accented bhráter but patér, Verner's law applies to the second, and all the correspondences are once more regular.

Lack of data is one reason why apparent exceptions continue to be problematic. Languages go extinct and information is lost. Another problem is that subsequent changes can overlay the results of former ones. The English and German words for father illustrate this. In German a second sound shift applied in the early Middle Ages, like a repeated application of Grimm's Law. Water became Wasser and Vader became Vater (at the same time - the t > ss change didn't then apply to the new t arising from d.)

The English illustrates a different subverter of regularity: analogy. The ancestral PIE word máter became mother in Old English, so they had fader, mother, brother. Analogy is a well-known influence that causes forms to change. The change from fader to modern father might have been because of some later sound law in Middle English, but I don't know of any that would do this. Levelling by analogy is the simplest explanation.

In the early 1900s the Neogrammarian movement was opposed by a group called Neolinguists in Italy. They believed that individual mutations and idiosyncrasies could become established without an underlying general rule. They derived some support from the detailed linguistic atlas of France created by Jules Gilliéron, which showed wide varieties of word forms from region to region. However, Gilliéron was neogrammarian in explaining his forms. In 1953 the great linguist Joseph Greenberg could declare that the neolinguistic ideas were not generally accepted.


(definition) by Webster 1913 (print) Mon Jan 02 2006 at 18:47:41

Ne`o*gram*ma"ri*an (?), n. [Neo- + grammarian; a translation of G. junggrammatiker.]

One of a group of philologists who apply phonetic laws more widely and strictly than was formerly done, and who maintain that these laws admit of no real exceptions. -- Ne`o*gram*mat"ic*al (#), a.

 

© Webster 1913


printable version
chaos

Grimm's Law Verner's Law Proto-Indo-European Proto-Germanic
Linguistics Sporadic Neoterist Regularity
Phonetics cognitive linguistics Jugendstil Larry Trask
The Sensible Thing Lady Ferdinand de Saussure Eye in the Sky
Joseph Greenberg analogy Knoxville, Tennessee Indra's Net
Nembutsu Exceptionless sound phonetic
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help


cooled by dannye

Cool Staff Picks
Things you could have written:
Nike
Little Penguin Fashion
Ailurophobia
cigarette
For the Birds
co-sleeping
A short history in a long scar
How to talk to tech support
Everything Professional Career Network
Lateralus
An Intelligent Woman
Working in a greenhouse is sometimes as much fun as you think it might be.
Math is not a social construct
New Writeups
XWiz
Trism(review)
artman2003
Briefcase Full of Souls - Part I(fiction)
Dreamvirus
Alan Ladd(person)
waverider37
Harold Holt(person)
The Debutante
Until death do us part(fiction)
Ysardo
a brother to a sister(personal)
antigravpussy
your warm whispers(personal)
Clarke
Multiculturalism(idea)
aneurin
Earl of Landaff(person)
Heitah
Pseudocide(idea)
XWiz
Google Knol(lede)
Mythi
July 24, 2008(personal)
locke baron
The fall of Earth(fiction)
BookReader
Fear the Cold(dream)
Pavlovna
Kathleen MacInnes(person)
Everything 2 is brought to you by the letter C and The Everything Development Company