Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

transubstantiation only works if you accept Aristotelian metaphysics

created by graymalkn

(idea) by graymalkn (3.3 wk) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 1 C! Tue May 22 2001 at 18:08:26

Transubstantiation is the Catholic doctrine that during the sacrament of communion, the communion wafer actually and quite literally becomes the body of Christ in all ways but appearance. This is considered to be an honest-to-god miracle, true divine intervention in the universe.

Of course, the skeptic will point out that if it changes in all ways but appearance, what's the big miracle? The Catholic responds that God has changed the substance of the wafer, that what it is has changed (though this can only be perceived through faith). But what does this mean, that the substance of the wafer has changed? In our modern empirical world view, we tend to go on what properties we see in an object to tell us what it is- if those properties change, the thing becomes another thing; if those properties stay the same, the thing remains what it is.

When early Christianity was forming into a cohesive unit with what might be called an academic wing, it needed some sort of formal beliefs about the nature of the physical world and took on Aristotle as a guide. Many Aristotelian notions were taken as nearly (and sometimes actually) dogmatic. One of these was Aristotle's metaphysics. Without going into great detail, Aristotle regards any given thing as being, well, a particular thing and furthermore having certain qualities. That is, the red door might have the property of being red, but it is a door- that is the one and only category that it fits in to.

So what happens according to the doctrine of transubstantiation is that God causes the communion wafer to keep all its properties while at the same time changing the substance of it, something that is naturally impossible according to Aristotle, thus the miracle.


printable version
chaos

transubstantiation Names have power Programming for the End of the Day Butterfinger McFlurry
The Rise of Christianity How to flirt monasticism continuum
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Drink up!
Capuchin architecture
anthropic principle
black and tv blue
Candide
Turtles say "mmeh"
I called for the Emergency Destruct Plan
Georg Hegel
How to send a child to college
wave/particle duality
Children of the Corny: A Nodermeet Out on the Prairie
The Romantic Fallacy
I never thought it would be like this
Musikalisches Opfer
New Writeups
XWiz
Trism(review)
artman2003
Briefcase Full of Souls - Part I(fiction)
Dreamvirus
Alan Ladd(person)
waverider37
Harold Holt(person)
The Debutante
Until death do us part(fiction)
Ysardo
a brother to a sister(personal)
antigravpussy
your warm whispers(personal)
Clarke
Multiculturalism(idea)
aneurin
Earl of Landaff(person)
Heitah
Pseudocide(idea)
XWiz
Google Knol(lede)
Mythi
July 24, 2008(personal)
locke baron
The fall of Earth(fiction)
BookReader
Fear the Cold(dream)
Pavlovna
Kathleen MacInnes(person)
Everything 2 is brought to you by the letter C and The Everything Development Company