Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

nemo iudex in causa sua

created by whizkid

(idea) by whizkid (6 y) (print)   ?   1 C! I like it! Mon Sep 11 2000 at 22:25:14

Nemo iudex in causa sua, Latin for no one (is a) judge in (his) own case.

Originally a legal principle pertaining to ancient Roman judiciary, still an important principle of most modern legal systems.

The idea is that no one can decide his own case in the court of law. Even a judge cannot hear a case against himself.

The reason for this is fairly obvious, and it goes beyond the possibility that one might abuse the privilege of judging oneself and ruling in one's own favor. Rather, no matter how objective one may be in judging others, one can never keep the same objectivity towards oneself. Not even if one genuinely wanted to.

While this principle only applies to the judiciary, it is a very good principle to abide by in all aspects of life. That is why, for example, E2 noders cannot ching their own nodes.

It is also important to keep this principle in mind whenever another Latin principle is used, namely Caveat emptor (Let the buyer beware).

For example, recently Dateline NBC (an American TV show of investigative journalism) aired a segment about a mother whose son was born with a genetic predisposition for behaving in a way that might get him in trouble. Not knowing what to do, she consulted with her Pastor, who recommended a Bible based "school" in Texas.

It turned out that the "school" was actually a place of brutal abuse and torture, both physical and psychological. A place that could not pass state licensing requirements, and was forced to close its door until a new Governor of Texas (George W. Bush) decided that the state could not close a Bible based school.

A licensing body was still required but it had to be one created by religious institutions. As it turned out, the chairman of this "school" was one of the key members of the licensing board. In other words, he judged his own skills at running a school and passed himself with flying colors, while he apparently was not qualified (at least according to Dateline story). No doubt he believed that whatever was going on in the "school" was a good thing.

The mother told Dateline that, had she known about what was going on in the "school," she would have never subjected her son to its environment.


printable version
chaos

Caveat emptor C! Words that sound dirty but really aren't ad melius inquirendum
causa sui Plutocracy Latin law expressions objective
Latin Dateline NBC Criminality Editor Log: May 2001
The Laws of Thermodynamics applied to cleaning nemophila On being a staunch monarchist Baphomet
Editor Log: October 15, 2000 objectivity privilege principle
Judiciary judge George W. Bush Grimgribber
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Drink up!
Unification of Italy
It's all happy endings and meaningful conversation until someone gets hurt
The stars stood still and naked
The Mythological Origins of The Silmarillion and Unfinished Tales
Turnings in American history
You'll never work in dis bidness again
Tom Waits
Why are homosexuals held to different standards of conduct than heterosexuals?
Skunk Cabbage
Kilwa
interstellar travel
Attention
Irish Wake
New Writeups
Dreamvirus
the kingdom of now(poetry)
Gryffon
balls out(idea)
originalzin
The Healing Place(place)
TheLady
Why I love Everything2(essay)
jjen
Why I love Everything2(personal)
AspieDad
Fighting someone else's battle(idea)
santo
Rock Band vs. Guitar Hero III(essay)
impishlaugh
Threshold(idea)
maxClimb
May 21, 2008(log)
Rancid_Pickle
I Wish Momma Sang the Blues(fiction)
dannye
Lars and the Real Girl(review)
Glowing Fish
Educational gender gap(idea)
Venkman
Persimmon pudding(recipe)
aneurin
Hilary Armstrong(person)
giantcactus
The Power of Electricity(personal)
E2 is a by-product of the existence of The Everything Development Company