Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Where the Red Fern Grows

created by Jet-Poop

(idea) by wharfinger (6.2 y) (print)   ?   1 C! I like it! Tue May 02 2000 at 3:54:18

Why is it that any damn kids' book with a dog in it always ends up with "very, very sad times" at the end? Whose idea was it to kill off all those damn dogs? It never fails! Show me a book with large type and a happy damn dog on the front, and blammo, I guarantee the poor dumb animal's days are numbered, as sure as I stand here.

This is a special case of the Disney Principle, which applies to all cute animals: The inexorable and bloody-handed logic of children's entertainment dictates that All Things Cute Must Die. Boy-and-his dog books are aimed at an older audience than Disney movies, but never mind that. The cuteness flux wanes as the target approaches puberty, but the end is the same.

Maybe the Disney Principle and the boy-and-his dog book dead puppy imperative are both special cases of something deeper and more sinister. Yeah, shmaltz, kitsch, whatever, but there is only one plot in a non-comedy story involving animals.

I mean hey, I don't much like dogs myself: They stink, they're dependent, they're born slaves, etc. Even so, they surely deserve to come into this world with some hope of living long enough to star in the sequel.

Hm, Lassie is an exception.


(idea) by hamster bong (1.1 wk) (print)   ?   I like it! Tue May 02 2000 at 4:57:39

I think that people are looking at this novel in the wrong light entirely. I mean, yes, it does involve dogs and there is an element of sadness to it.. but it's about life, the entire novel is about life and devotion and love, and it's kind of sad to see it broken down into some book about "cute things" dying.

Also, I have to point out that Where the Red Fern Grows isn't a boy and his dog book so much as a two dogs and pure, hardcore emotion. I don't remember the parts of the story that dealt with the boy nearly as well as I remember those which were solely about the animals. That may sound silly.. but I tend to think that dogs are passionate animals. The story is touching, and yes, it is also quite sad, but life is sad. Sometimes the most achingly beautiful things in life are also those that emanate with sadness.

It's easy to peg a book like this one down as being a travesty to dogs, or something along those lines, or even as just another Disney type flick.. but if you really read it, actually pay attention to it, it's a nice story. I like the fact that the boy in the book can see the bond between the two animals, but a lot of people reading don't understand. I think it's sort of a testament to the kind of devotion you just don't see very often anymore.. perhaps this is why so many people miss it in the novel.

printable version
chaos

A Day No Pigs Would Die Coon Achingly beautiful Are you pondering what I'm pondering?
I Heard The Owl Call My Name Eulogy for a Burnt Kitten We need to watch things die The full moon made me do it
Hannibal Bridge to Terabithia Principle of maximum entropy don't judge a book by its movie
Everything 2 Editors Catch-22 Dream Log: May 1, 2000 animals
All Creatures Great and Small I saw a kitten This product was tested on cute, furry animals with big, sad eyes Old Yeller
Samuel R. Delany Ozarks Lassie emotion
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Just another sprinkling of indeterminacy
VNV Nation
Words that are supposedly untranslatable
Where were you when someone asked where you were when something happened
We don't write poetry because it's cute
Staring down babies
The cactus that told me my mom was asleep
Ann Coulter
On Travelling the Pilgrimage of Shikoku
Fat Albert and the Cosby Kids
The logic of atheism
Barack Obama's Speech at the Democratic National Convention, 2004
Arecibo Observatory
King of Birds
New Writeups
Ereneta
Stone Soup, Part Two(person)
jjen
Sorrier than I ever thought I would be(personal)
locke baron
Moskva class antisubmarine cruiser(thing)
Wuukiee
May 15, 2008(idea)
locke baron
Kuznetsov class aircraft carrier(thing)
_lesra
for abby(thing)
Adaptive Child
Annie's garden salsa(recipe)
Simulacron3
Zig-Zag(thing)
Ouzo
Special Grilled Cheese(fiction)
Noung
Tiananmen Square Massacre(idea)
aneurin
Lord St Clair(person)
artman2003
Assholes and Douchebags: A Comparison(person)
locke baron
Tyan Thunder K8WE(thing)
locke baron
Udaloy class destroyer(thing)
Scaevola
Same-sex marriage(idea)
This page courtesy of The Everything Development Company