Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Should you have to understand lyrics to enjoy the music?

created by blowdart

(idea) by nieken (5.3 y) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 1 C! Sat Jun 17 2000 at 16:10:05

This question has bothered me for years. I have reduced it to what I call the Nirvana and Tool Philosophies of Music Appreciation.

The Nirvana Argument So named because Kurt Cobain and tribe always felt that people should understand songs, and the message behind songs, rather than simply consume them. Understanding was crucial to enjoyment, and even of being "qualified" to listen to the music. Observe the chorus from their song In Bloom:

He's the one who likes
All our pretty songs and he
Likes to sing along and he
Likes to shoot his gun but he
Knows not what it means


The Tool Argument So named because Maynard and crew have expressed in numerous interviews over the years that they make music that sounds good. It also has deep, often well-hidden, meanings. But according to the band, they are satisfied if people simply like their music. It is merely an added bonus if they understand it, but hardly crucial.


My take on all this has always been, if musicians and other artists want people to understand them, they need to be more obvious. Poetry (or song lyrics, as it were) are usually wrought with undefined symbols and purposely obfuscated metaphors. Proper communication depends on clearly defined symbols and unambiguous messages. This is the difference between poetry and prose, in that prose uses clearly defined rules of semantics for the formatting of communication (grammar), plus a clearly defined lexicon of symbols (a dictionary). From this, people can communicate and be assured of understanding (if they follow the rules, of course). The problem with asking people to understand lyrics before they can enjoy music is that by doing so you are asking people to (often times) wade though unclear poetic metaphors without giving them the resources to understand. I mean, what if you speak a different language? You can't whine that nobody understands you when you don't give them the ability to. That is, when you don't define your symbols.

Likewise, if they just wanted to communicate a message, why all the noise in the background? Why have all that pounding away going on and undulating, melodic speech? It just makes it hard to hear (Nirvana is, of course, the perfect example of this). Musicians like making music. Music sound good. Not too many people derive deep meaning from mere instrumentals (basic emotions, sure, but rarely something as complicated or high-level as words express). If musicians weren't interested in the rhythms and such of the musical component, and only in the lyrical aspect of a song, we would probably call them poets.

(idea) by mcd (1.8 wk) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 1 C! Fri Mar 21 2003 at 21:57:03

Yes, a writeup is supposed to stand on its own (and hopefully this one will) but a node exists as its whole as well. It has been said above used to say, kind of snuck in at the end, that 'Not too many people derive deep meaning from mere instrumentals (basic emotions, sure, but rarely something as complicated or high-level as words express).' Having the 'Not too many people' tagged onto the front brings up the argument of whether the general populace has a good understanding of music or not, but it is not my intention to take this writeup in that direction. Rather, I want to elucidate the very real physical connection in the brain between language, melody, harmony and rhythm.

Coming from the ear, the first part of the brain that processes music is the brain stem. This is where the crudest processing is done as this part of the brain is usually associated with the primordial vestiges of say, locating prey or avoiding a predator. It helps to shape sounds and identify individual notes before passing the information onto the auditory cortex where more complex processing is achieved. Once here sounds are placed in context of what follows and precedes them. The right-brain cortex determines hierarchies of harmonic relations while the left forms the sequencing of sounds and the perception of rhythm. Here is where an intriguing overlapping of brain function occurs. The right cortex is particularly adept at analyzing the harmonic vowel sounds of language while the left is involved in the sequencing of words and ideas. In fact, the left side is considered the seat of language in the brain! In some experiments, prenatal exposure to music has produced an accelerated acquisition of language skills, such as babbling.

Indeed, music is a language all its own. It is a language that has the unique ability to conjure a complex emotional range that is comprised of but not limited to nostalgia, tension, tranquility, elation, depression and even fear. Studies show that music elicits a complex interaction with endorphins and neurotransmitters in the brain. The pleasing effect of melodies and harmonies are first mediated by personal as well as cultural preference. Individuals are greatly influenced by the tones found in their native language which in turn influences their native music. Some may also have a greater understanding or predilection towards music and tend to respond or interact on a deeper level with it than they ever could with the spoken or written word.


printable version
chaos

Turning your computer off with your foot Tool: The most difficult music in modern rock No I'm the most off-beat genius you ever knew; I'm so iconoclastic I'm clastic
My Bloody Valentine What to do if you've got too many votes on your hands Parental Advisory: Explicit Lyrics There is good country music
Cradle of Filth Nirvana Afro Celt Sound System Supposing that I should have the courage
Getting to know you noders fucking sucked Rage Against The Machine Pizzicato Five Rodimus Prime
Holy, Holy, Holy! Lord God Almighty Cocteau Twins Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan Super Furry Animals
Japan's Gross National Cool Belle and Sebastian Caroliner Modes of ethical discourse
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
What you are reading:
If God did not exist, it would be necessary to invent him
In his autumn before the winter comes man's last mad surge of youth
Wildfire
Eddie Izzard
Why the rich get richer and the poor get poorer
I'd dance forever if they'd let me, you know
steel drum
William Shakespeare
Radiohead
The Fall of the Roman Empire
Replaceable Parts
Mad Magazine
Dissertation defense
New Writeups
anndandridge
Dorothy Dandridge(person)
PaulM
ignominity(idea)
Clarke
Multiculturalism(idea)
aneurin
Earl of Landaff(person)
Heitah
Pseudocide(idea)
XWiz
Google Knol(lede)
Mythi
July 24, 2008(personal)
locke baron
The fall of Earth(fiction)
BookReader
Fear the Cold(dream)
Pavlovna
Kathleen MacInnes(person)
stainedglass
1(fiction)
kalen
Three "T"s(idea)
octillion369
Undead(idea)
archiewood
Ico(fiction)
Heisenberg
Why I love Everything2(log)
Everything 2 is brought to you by the letter C and The Everything Development Company