Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Life of a pig

created by Pseudo_Intellectual

(idea) by Pseudo_Intellectual (2.8 wk) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 1 C! Thu Aug 03 2000 at 21:37:24

This was the state of mind in which I paid my first visit to Italy and Sicily. When I arrived I found nothing whatever to please me in the tastes of a society devoted to Italian and Syracusan cookery, where happiness was held to consist in filling oneself full twice a day, never sleeping alone at night, and indulging in the other pursuits that go with such a way of living. Brought up from boyhood in such an environment no man under heaven could become wise - he would need to be endowed with a temperment altogether miraculous - nor would he be any more likely to acquire self-control and the other qualities which go to make up goodness. Similarly no state, whatever its constitution, can enjoy peace and quietness if the citizens believe luxury to be the only proper object of expenditure and hold that men should be free from all other business to devote themselves entirely to feasting and drinking and the pursuit of love.

- Plato, the Seventh letter.

Reputedly Socrates' metaphorical name for a way of life in which no mindspace is allotted for possibly unanswerable philosophical quandaries - inasmuch as a pig presumably doesn't have the intellectual capabilities of postulating as to the nature of the universe, truth, God, knowledge and the soul, someone who has been equipped with the requisite intellect and refuses to exercise it may as well, like a pig, not possess the capability at all.

Aristotle, the pupil of Socrates' pupil (Plato), arrived at much the same conclusion in his Nichomachian Ethics, coming from the other direction and dismissing a life dedicated to pleasure (hedone, presumably the satisfaction of simple physical urges - a good meal, a good shit, a good rut) as slavish and only fit for animals, then going through and back into familiar territory as he proposes that the highest happiness (eudaimonia) is only attainable through the philosophical speculation, or theoria, which is closest to the activities of the Gods.

For centuries afterwards, Stoics pulled out the same swinish rhetoric on followers of Epicurus, and in the nineteenth century John Stuart Mill said in Utilitarianism that it was better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a pig satisfied (or rather, "It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied; better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied."), perhaps contradicting Aristotle's earlier premise about philosophy leading to happiness but still strongly in support of the examined life of philosophy as an important thing if not necessarily a successful route to happiness.

When contacted for a comment, local pigs were only heard to say "Oink," but it looked like they were smiling.

(contrast, perhaps with Montaigne's account of Pyrrho's pig.)


printable version
chaos

'Tis better to die as a lion than to live 1000 years as a dog Oink The cactus that told me my mom was asleep intellectual
Only a simple computer program : 2 Stoic mindspace Sense and Sensibility - Chapter 47
pro-life Nebraska Man life cycle analysis Suidae
me So I was balls deep in the guy's ass that night when he turns to me and asks for a kiss. Damn. What a fag. Death was a part of me then, too. I remember when it was me who made her toilet flush
I remember when it was me who made her skin flush I was once smaller than a jellybean, but now look at me - I am macroscopic! I was a homeless bum I Hear it was Charged Against Me
You knew I was a rattlesnake when you picked me up I was discovered by scientists, what will they call me? hedonism Happiness
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Nodes to live by:
There is good rap music
The One
Laos
booster
BBC Radio 4
Thank you for not sharing
Getting an STI test
E2 Visual Basic hardlinking utility
Cypherpunk
The Art of Bitchcraft
anthropic principle
The Lofoten Maelstrom
Perl
New Writeups
BookReader
Fear the Cold(dream)
Pavlovna
Kathleen MacInnes(person)
stainedglass
1(fiction)
kalen
Three "T"s(idea)
octillion369
Undead(idea)
archiewood
Ico(fiction)
Heisenberg
Why I love Everything2(log)
octillion369
Death Knight(person)
XWiz
Are you hoping for a miracle?(review)
santo
The Host(review)
LostPsion
"Shut the Fuck Up" Theaters(idea)
beatrice
You've been slowly taking me over for nearly a year, do you know that?(idea)
Berek
YouTube(thing)
shaogo
How to Pretend to Have a Job(idea)
hapax
Les Provinciales(review)
This page courtesy of The Everything Development Company