Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Let them eat cake

created by Dialogue

(thing) by Taltos (5.2 y) (print)   ?   I like it! Sat Oct 07 2000 at 20:41:48

A statement attributed to Marie Antoinette from the French Revolution. Peasant crowds were gathering and complaining that there was no bread in the bakeries so they were starving. When Marie asked what the problem was, her response was "Let them eat cake!"

In some history books this is widely noted as an indicator of how out of touch the ruling class was from their populace and an example of why the revolution was justified because "The people are starving? Then let them eat desert."

As wildly obvious as this may seem, it is just wrong. Cake today is universally (ok, at least here in the USA) seen as a wonderful sweet treat. The term cake in the context of Antoinette's reference is the crumbly leftovers at the bottom of the oven when bread or pastries are baked. So instead this is an indicator of how out of touch the ruling class was from their populace and an example of why the revolution was justified because "The people are starving? Then let them eat crumbs."


(thing) by tongpoo (3.8 wk) (print)   ?   I like it! Sat Dec 16 2000 at 17:29:08

When informed that the lower classes of France were starving, their supply of moldy bread running out, Marie-Antoinette has been thought to have said four insensitive little words that would forever brand her as cruel and greedy: "Let them eat cake."

- from the book "Confessions," by Jean Jacques Rousseau

Marie-Antoinette was falsly accused of making such comment in a publication two years before her reign as queen. The closest it ever got was Marie Therese, wife of Louis XIV, saying "Qu'ils mangent de la brioche," which means "Let them eat bread."  This correction is presented to tourists who visit the Versailles as a fact agreed upon by historians. She also went around France helping the poor, by the way. The misquote is an example of slanders made against her that shows how unpopular the woman from a different cultural background was, even before becoming a queen.

During the French Revolution, Marie-Antoinette was beheaded on the guillotine. Not much was known about economic depression back then, and the poor needed a scapegoat.

References: http://pages.about.com/versailles/marieantoinette.html
...and palace of Versailles tour.

printable version
chaos

blowing a fag What loan words say about a society Marie Antoinette There shall be no more cakes and ale?
He who has enough to eat does the hungry not believe fuckwit Someone left the cake out in the rain Rose petal fairy cakes
Everything will be required of us, and everything will be given You do not have a right to not be offended Eccles Cake Wayne Thiebaud
Civic Orientation and Consumerism Famous Last Words Louis XIV French alphabet
DO NOT EAT THE URINAL CAKES guillotine Illuminati: New World Order Why neither the French nor the Italians are the worst military nation
petit four Death by cake Word to your mother The Condition of the Working Class in England
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
What you are reading:
The Bloody Code
Oxford English Dictionary
Anonymous honesty may destroy me.
The next revolution in music has not yet arrived
Can we cure AIDS?
Gone to Hell to fight the Devil
Hausdorff distance
RumourQuest 2006
ApoxyButt's Guide to Successful Boating
Falling in love with your best friend
punctuation
Mulholland Drive
spleen
New Writeups
allthetime
Apple Cinnamon Suicide(idea)
Lucy-S
shovelglove(idea)
Adaptive Child
Mexican secret sauce(recipe)
Adaptive Child
nacho libre(recipe)
TheLady
Iron Man(review)
Scaevola
Risk in the Roman law of sale(idea)
semicolon
overheard at IHOP(event)
choirotey
Violent pickup lines(idea)
Ouzo
Blue Ovaries, Grrrrrrwl(log)
uncljoedoc
explanation(person)
Noung
One no longer loves one's insight when one communicates it(idea)
AspieDad
Pornology(essay)
nailbiter
Nicole duFresne(person)
Simulacron3
stigmergy(idea)
nakusavi
Yesterday I learned how to kiss(idea)
E2 is a by-product of the existence of The Everything Development Company