Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Is this poetry or crap?

created by Nurlman

(idea) by Nurlman (5.7 y) (print)   ?   12 C!s I like it! Mon Aug 20 2001 at 18:34:04

In high school, my English teacher,
having apparently surrendered any vestige of what once may have been
genuine pedagogical instincts,
had us write down the lyrics to our favorite song.
Ostensibly, this was an effort
(a somewhat lazy and intellecually dishonest one,
if you ask me),
to introduce us to the concept of "poetry."
The girl sitting next to me
effusively wrote down every inane word of Silent Running, by Mike + The Mechanics,
a song that to me, even at the impressionable age of 15,
seemed vapid.
Which caused me to ask myself:
Is this poetry or crap?

I've read sonnets,
And I've read odes,
And I've read loads,
Of poetry nodes.

I've looked for meter
And searched for rhyme
And nearly every time
I think to myself: Is this poetry or crap?

So many "poets"
reject the repressive patriarchal fascist hegemony of Eurocentric A-B-A-B structures,
opting, instead, for a free-flowing "style,"
characterized primarily by
line breaks
for
no
apparent reason,
as if the pauses, in and of themselves, convey a meaning,
instead of the words doing most of the heavy lifting.

Don't get me wrong:
Mike + The Mechanics rhyme
and they still suck.
Rhyme and meter are no substitute
for having something worthwhile to say.
And if you don't really have anything to say
(or, more likely, have something to say
but you're not really sure what it is yet)
chopping it up into little nuggets
doesn't make it any more palatable.

It seems to me
free verse poetry
is primarily
a place for thee
with an itchy finger on the "Enter" key.

Oh, and the guy who said repetition of common words and phrases makes excellent postmodern poetry
was onto something too.
(Assuming it was satirical)
(And these days, who can tell anymore?)
Why not just an
endless
string of non-sequiturs?
Like: Gumdrop licking nightmare happy balloon watershed?
That creates "imagery," too, you know.
Sure, it may not mean the same thing to you
the reader,
that it does to me,
the author,
But this is the age of deconstructionism
and meaning is relative anyway.

So just because these words don't mean a goddamned thing to me
doesn't mean I should deprive
you
of them,
on the off chance that they'll trigger an epiphany
in you.
Or is it, as I suspect, just the opposite?

I'm sure it is a heresy
to impugn one's creativity,
to cavalierly rip apart
words poured from someone else's heart.
For who am I to criticize--
simply because I have eyes
that read the words upon the page
but fail to feel the poet's rage?
Or worse, to generalize as such
all works with a poetic touch
as merely self-indulgent pap
by asking "Is this poetry or crap?"

I stand prepared to face the stones
of those with verses in their bones
and to incur the wrath of those
who think the Emperor's wearing clothes.
You budding poets should feel free
to castigate and punish me,
but let my taunts to you inspire
responses of some quantum higher
than formless wads of half-baked screeds
sprinkled freely with line feeds.


printable version
chaos

Repetition of common words and phrases makes excellent postmodern poetry free verse Silent Running It's as easy to write bad poetry as it is to breathe
Things on e2 other than XP that will make you happy My penis shall not suffer as a result of this horrible poetry! I walked barefoot through hell, thanks for asking who vs. whom
your words... like wind through a wheat field. Too much bad poetry on E2 Bad teenage poetry The Very Model of an Eliminative Materialist
I wanted to touch him so badly that it made my fingertips burn You are going to need to get a big princess type dress. I CANNOT fight for the honor of someone wearing cowgirl pjs Mike Rutherford Do not go gentle into that good night
You do realize that this is not, in any meaningful sense, a martini, don't you? I can't decide if what you're saying is too profound for me to comprehend or just insane Where kisses take us crap
John Ashbery I am in love with so much more than your body heat, but let's start there bad poetry Casey at the Bat
No more writeups are being accepted for this node. If you have to ask, it's probably crap. If you feel you have something to add to this node, post it on your Scratch Pad and contact an editor.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Little presents from the Node Fairy:
156/98
George W. Bush's address to the UN General Assembly: September 12, 2002
Japan's 21st century crisis
Ironic hipsters
Tank Girl
public key cryptography
Language is like a river
Marvel Comics
An area the size of Wales
Double space after a period at the end of a sentence
Kilwa
Throwing sparks, growing dahlias
Anacletus
New Writeups
Ouzo
Goodwill Hunting, Thrift Store(ies)(log)
Pandeism Fish
How conatus compels divine ketosis through a radical kenosis(essay)
cryforhelp
Major dictionaries of the world(review)
Glowing Fish
The Uncanny X-Men and the New Teen Titans(thing)
WolfKeeper
Launch loop(idea)
TendoKing
Katana(person)
Wuukiee
Highly ornamental cultivars of brambles still have as many thorns as their wild counterparts(idea)
TheDeadGuy
Editor Log: May 2008(log)
everyday j.Lo
pray do not molest them(thing)
ammie
Bands Who Take Their Names from Eighteenth-century English Poetry and Prose(idea)
shaogo
Under My Thumb(review)
ammie
Rock On(person)
The Custodian
The Dresden Files(thing)
Ouzo
PETA becomes you, a proposed future(fiction)
Ereneta
Stone Soup, Part Two(fiction)
E2 is a by-product of the existence of The Everything Development Company