Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

For every set there exists a larger set

created by Gorgonzola

(idea) by Gorgonzola (9.1 hr) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 1 C! Mon Jun 26 2000 at 3:09:43

A set or class is "larger" than another set or class if the first set is of "higher power" than the second set, that is, if there exists a one-to-one correspondence between the entire second set and a subset of the first, but no such correspondence between the entire first set and a subset of the second.

What follows is a representation of Georg Cantor's proof, as filtered through the axiom system of Paul Bernays. Please notice that the entire proof derives from more mundane axioms of set theory without requiring more controversial ones like the Axiom of Choice.

If you don't understand the notation follow this link.

Given a set a, consider a one-to-one correspondence F between a and a class C of subsets of a. We must prove there is a subset of a which cannot belong to C, meaning there is no possible one-to-one correspondence (or even a merely surjective mapping) between a and the class of all subsets of a (which we'll call Π(a)).

This subset, call it t, is a ∩ {x|x ∉ F(x)}.

  • t ⊆ a. The intersection of a with anything is always a subset of a.
  • By our definition of t, c ∈ t <-> c ∈ a & c ∉ F(c)
  • which means (c ∈ a & t = F(c)) -> (c ∈ t <-> c ∉ t)
  • so, c ∈ t -> t != F(c) This is what we wanted to prove. t is not in C = Δ2F because it cannot be the image in F for any subset of a!

Because of you can never have a one-to-one correspondence between a and Π(a), you can always construct a class of subsets of a which has higher power than a.

When you accept the potency axiom, the class Π(a) is represented by the set π(a), and so you must conclude that there exist sets (such as π(a)) which are of higher power than a.

The famous diagonal argument of Cantor demonstrates a special (perhaps "clearer"?) case of the proof, one which specifically denies the existence of a one-to-one corespondence between the integers and the reals. t is the generalization of the number created by taking a "diagonal" through the digit representations of the real numbers in the attempted one-to-one correspondence.


(idea) by tongpoo (2.8 mon) (print)   ?   (I like it!) Mon Feb 04 2002 at 18:03:31

Another rendition of Georg Cantor's proof with more modern notations.

Theorem

For any set A, the power set P(A) is larger than A. This holds since there exists an obvious injection from A to P(A), and not so obvious, there does not exist a surjection from A to P(A).

Proof by contradiction

Suppose there exists surjective f: A → P(A).
Let B = {a ∈ A : a !∈ f(a)}. ("!∈" meaning "not in," for browsers that don't support ∉)
Since B ∈ P(A) and f surjective, ∃ b ∈ A : f(b) = B.
But b exists neither in B nor not in B! Contradiction. ∴ Surjective f cannot exist.

Russell was one of the people who asked about the case where A contained everything. This line of thought lead to the celebrated Russell's Paradox. To resolve this paradox, modern axiomatic set theory was developed. (see: ZF, Axiom of Choice)

printable version
chaos

potency axiom Russell's paradox There are as many numbers between 0 and 1 as there are in the set of all real numbers set theory notation
lonely runner problem number theory bigger breasts diagonal argument
ZF power set Cantor diagonalization Hilbert Hotel
surjective Axiom of Choice Catechism Georg Cantor
Mapping the power set of the integers to the real numbers Filling an infinite park with cars Fermat's Last Theorem Bernstein's Theorem
Proof by contradiction Density of Irrational Numbers Theorem: Proof novel positional notation
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Just another sprinkling of indeterminacy
I glimpse the elephant
Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
Chamonix
David Icke
She will remember your heart when men are fairy tales in books written by rabbits
Enron and the Cult of Personality
condom man page
Wanted: Supervillain minions
Sohei
Caffe Pergolesi
I'm scared to run the program I wrote
Buying a house
Blindsight
New Writeups
Ctrl Y
cognitive dissonance(fiction)
SharQ
Gone Baby Gone(review)
halfWit
If I could, I'd title this "Freedom"(thing)
Roninspoon
Airline Hero(thing)
Ktistec
Why Women Are Always Cold(person)
doctor wilson
Drug policy reform(thing)
tejasa
Easy Raspberry Cheesecake(recipe)
Joysim
Drug policy reform(idea)
aneurin
Tyburn(place)
niruena
Boiling to death(idea)
artman2003
summer(thing)
doctor wilson
The Silver City and the Silent Sea(log)
Dreamvirus
The Silver City and the Silent Sea(poetry)
Aerobe
A nihilist's soulmate(poetry)
BookReader
Soup, of the green variety(recipe)
Everything 2 is brought to you by the letter C and The Everything Development Company