Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Ethical absolutes

created by hectorthebat

(idea) by hectorthebat (4.1 wk) (print)   ?   (I like it!) Sat Jan 04 2003 at 20:06:06

By an 'absolute' value or good is meant one that maintains its validity under any and every circumstance, no matter what. For example the ancient maxim of the Stoics 'Let justice be done though the heavens fall' is a dramatic way of expressing the absolute validity of justice as a principle. With the moral theologians of the Middle Ages, the general principle 'Follow the good and avoid the evil' was regarded as a major or ultimate premise carrying with it absolute validity. In more modern philosophy the ethics of Immanuel Kant furnishes the best example of an ethical absolute. Good will, which Kant defined as the will that acts out of respect for the moral law, has absolute validity; it is good in any context and has a worth that cannot be calculated because it surpasses all values in exchange.

Ethical absolutes come under attack from at least three distinct points of view. From the point of view of some forms of subjectivism in ethics there can be no absolutes because moral judgements have neither objectivity nor universality and there is not sufficient constancy in human nature to guarantee for any good or value a place of absolute validity. It is useful to notice that not all forms of subjectivism are thus relativistic, but only those positions according to which human nature has no universal structure. The second and more powerful source of relativism in ethics stems from anthropological and cultural analyses that make paramount the great variety of customs and practices to be found in different cultures. From this point of view, ethical absoulutes are ruled out because there cannot possibly be a universal agreement or consensus of opinion with regard to any standard or norm. Each set of values is 'relative' to a geographical time and place and we have no way of transcending this situation and of establishing any one set of norms as the final criterion.

Ethical absolutes have also been attacked from a third source, this time in the name of a religious standpoint. Kierkegaard, for example, in his famous 'teleological suspension of the ethical' was calling attention to the problems that arise when the ethical standpoint is absolutized and becomes free of any critical vantage point beyond itself. If the ethical becomes absolute then legalism and moralism result. The ethical must be limited by the mercy and forgiveness of the religious and if it is not, the ethical will absolutize itself with evil consequences. A similar point about absoluitizing the ethical is made from the standpoint of dialectical theology so-called; the counsels of perfection stemming from the teaching of Jesus are not meant to apply absolutely and literally to the world of actual existence but rather are said to define the ideal standard in terms of which humanity and the world are judged. As absolute, the Christian ethic is said to be an 'impossible ideal,' and yet it retains its relevance for historical life.


printable version
chaos

Ethical relativism vs. ethical absolutism gone stoic in silence: ash and smoke and the wide sunk mud-iron landscape of forever Subjectivism Your ideas are intriguing to me and I wish to subscribe to your newsletter
lethal injection July 8, 2005 moral relativism Deontology
typo Christian Jesus Moralism
Legalism abortion Middle Ages relativism
Immanuel Kant Everything Noder Pageant 2003
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
After stirring Everything, these nodes rose to the top:
The Gone, Growing in Number
The revolution will not be webcast
nut, anklenut, kaatunut, donfreenut
by my own admission
Candiru
Danzayémon, Chief of the Etas
Mark Twain
Where was her angel all those times the sky clouded over
Ariel Sharon
Philip II
The "Fuck you, clown!" story
What is Everything?
Living up to your potential
New Writeups
a8ksh4
regret(idea)
Heisenberg
Editor Log: July 2008(log)
sam512
halfway homes, catacombs, twilight zones(fiction)
Timeshredder
The Texas UFO Crash of 1897(event)
Heitah
The Dark Knight(review)
ignis_glaciesque
Uppsala(place)
ignis_glaciesque
diffusion of responsibility(idea)
TheOrientalAfrican
The Soft Meadow of my Childhood(event)
BookReader
The Dragon Slayers(fiction)
kohlcass
religiously fashionable(review)
Pavlovna
waulking song(thing)
tentative
Stick Man(poetry)
Ereneta
The Fight with the Snapping Turtle: Or, the American St. George(poetry)
sitaraika
Fog and fire(personal)
MonoliTheory
She sobs in response(fiction)
Everything 2 is brought to you by the letter C and The Everything Development Company