Citicorp Crisis

created by tallman

(idea) by tallman (1.4 d) (print) ? (I like it!) 3 C!s Fri Feb 08 2002 at 19:28:51

In 1978, William J. LeMessurier, one of the nation's leading structural engineers, received a phone call from an engineering student in New Jersey. The young man was tasked with writing a paper about the unique design of the Citicorp tower in New York. The building's dramatic design was necessitated by the placement of a church. Rather than tear down the church, the designers, Hugh Stubbins and Bill LeMessurier, set their fifty-nine-story tower on four massive, nine-story-high stilts, and positioned them at the center of each side rather than at each corner. This daring scheme allowed the designers to cantalever the building's four corners, allowing room for the church beneath the northwest side. (see the pictures, listed below)

Thanks to the prodding of the student (whose name was lost in the swirl of subsequent events), LeMessurier discovered a subtle conceptual error in the design of the building's wind braces; they were unusually sensitive to certain kinds of winds known as quartering winds. This alone wasn't cause for worry, as the wind braces would absorb the extra load under normal circumstances. But the circumstances were not normal. Apparently, there had been a crucial change during their manufacture (the braces were fastened together with bolts instead of welds, as welds are generally considered to be stronger than necessary and overly expensive; furthermore the contractors had interpreted the New York building code in such a way as to exempt many of the tower's diagonal braces from loadbearing calculations, so they had used far too few bolts.) which multiplied the strain produced by quartering winds. Statistically, the possibility of a storm severe enough to tear the joint apart was once every sixteen years (what meteorologists call a sixteen year storm). This was alarmingly frequent. To further complicate matters, hurricane season was fast approaching.

The potential for a complete catastrophic failure was there, and because the building was located in Manhattan, the danger applied to nearly the entire city. The fall of the Citicorp building would likely cause a domino effect, wreaking a devestating toll of destruction in New York.

The story of this oversight, though amazing, is dwarfed by the series of events that led to the building's eventual structural integrity. To avert disaster, LeMessurier quickly and bravely blew the whistle - on himself. LeMessurier and other experts immediately drew up a plan in which workers would reinforce the joints by welding heavy steel plates over them.

Astonishingly, just after Citicorp issued a bland and uninformative press release, all of the major newspapers in New York went on strike. This fortuitous turn of events allowed Citicorp to save face and avoid any potential embarrassment. Construction began immediately, with builders and welders working from 5 p.m. until 4 a.m. to apply the steel "band-aids" to the ailing joints. They built plywood boxes around the joints, so as not to disturb the tenants, who remained largely oblivious to the seriousness of the problem.

"Instead of lawsuits and public panic, the Citicorp crisis was met with efficient teamwork and a swift solution. In the end, LeMessurier's reputation was enhanced for his courageous honesty, and the story of Citicorp's building is now a textbook example of how to respond to a high-profile, potentially disastrous problem."

Pictures of the unique Citicorp tower:
http://www.bluffton.edu/~sullivanm/stubbins/citicorp.html
http://www.bluffton.edu/~sullivanm/stubbins/ccshaft.jpg
http://www.lehigh.edu/~inctbuh/bom_citi_graphics/citicorp_montage.jpg

Thanks to mkb for making me find new pics to replace the old ones!

Sources:
Most of this information came from a New Yorker article by Joe Morgenstern (published May 29, 1995). This article also appears to have inspired these webpages: http://onlineethics.org/moral/LeMessurier/lem.html and http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/pisa/moncit.html

printable version
chaos

whistleblower	Citigroup	Citibank	Cantalever
Glass-Steagall Act	Manhattan	Westlake Center	Home designs and styles
John Reed	The Simpsons/Futurama Crossover Crisis II	Yu-Gi-Oh!	Quartering Act
Fun with telemarketing calls	Effective advertising through annoyance	New York	Theories of Ethics
Ethics	The Insider	Brace	civil engineering
structural engineering	architecture	structural integrity	stilts

Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.

Login
Password

remember me
password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Look at this mess the Death Borg made!
pseudoscience
So much for the nodegel Standards Committee.
the death of a child
John W. Campbell
Things Fall Apart
Our common enemy
Anne Frank
Iraqi Republican Guard
Mexican-American War
Fine paintbrush, light strokes, special paint
Encyclopedia on a toothpick
gosh darn it!
Internet piracy and the working writer

sitaraika
Colours	(idea)
etouffee
Wild tides guard her secrets	(poetry)
Lord Brawl
Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog	(review)
a8ksh4
regret	(idea)
Heisenberg
Editor Log: July 2008	(log)
sam512
halfway homes, catacombs, twilight zones	(fiction)
Timeshredder
The Texas UFO Crash of 1897	(event)
Heitah
The Dark Knight	(review)
ignis_glaciesque
Uppsala	(place)
ignis_glaciesque
diffusion of responsibility	(idea)
TheOrientalAfrican
The Soft Meadow of my Childhood	(event)
BookReader
The Dragon Slayers	(fiction)
kohlcass
religiously fashionable	(review)
Pavlovna
waulking song	(thing)
tentative
Stick Man	(poetry)

Everything 2 is brought to you by the letter C and The Everything Development Company