Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Boys, girls, and their mirror neurons

created by montecarlo

(idea) by montecarlo (2.6 d) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 2 C!s Thu Jan 01 2004 at 14:33:56

Are mirror neurons behind behavior differences between boys and girls?

Most small boys insist playing with trucks, most small girls with dolls, as every parent knows. It doesn't matter if the parent tries to give toy trucks to doll-preferential girls and Barbie dolls to truck-preferential boys, the "wrong gender toys" are simply rejected. For some people, this seems to point to the existence of innate gender differences.

However, such observations don't tell us which these innate differences are, specifically. To maintain that small boys have got their keen interest in trucks from evolution is clearly absurd. Nor is there anything inherently "male" about trucks -- any woman can drive a truck as well as a man; some actually do.

Preferential imitation

It is more likely that there is a "mirror neuron" mechanism at play here. The mirror neurons of girls may have been programmed by evolution to preferentially imitate what women around them do, and the boys' mirror neurons preferentially to what men are doing. Almost all truck-drivers in our society today happen to be men, almost all caretakers of babies are women. What men and women in society are doing differently at any particular time is the "gender culture" of this society at this particular time. If the theory (or hypothesis, if you prefer) of gender-preferential mirror neurons holds water, then it is no wonder that the journey toward a society of gender equality proceeds at a snail's pace.

The role of role models

Every new generation of men and women has -- via their mirror neurons -- subconsciously trained itself to behave in exactly the same way, gender-wise, as the generation before them did. Whatever change there can be from generation to generation, must come from a calculated, conscious effort from adult members of the new generation to radically change their gender role. Only a few pioneers are willing to put in such a calculated and conscious effort, so the new role models for the children's mirror neurons are few and far between. Hence the gender culture changes very, very slowly from generation to generation, no matter what new legislation and progressive debaters are saying.

A testable hypothesis

Does this theory have any experimental, scientific basis? No, it's just a hypothesis, so far. But it is certainly testable, so hopefully a brave and ingenious neurologist will come forward and perform the necessary experiments. These are likely to show that the gender roles in today's society are not rigidly linked to our biologically determined sexual roles. Rather, they are linked to what adults of different genders happen to be doing differently in our particular culture, at this particular point of time.

Inspired by iceowl's Deals well with ambiguity: a savagely long wu about why boys are not like girls and other things.


printable version
chaos

Deals well with ambiguity: a savagely long writeup about why boys are not like girls and other things Does Nature matter? mirror neurons Mirror neuron
corpus callosum What are little girls made of? Gender Gender stereotypes
Nature vs. nurture gender identity gender roles sex and gender
Oreo January 3, 2004 She's so cute thorough neuropsychology of depression
Two Cultures Model of Gender Differences in Language Use Boys and Girls Evolution What are little boys made of?
Aw, Mom, ya know I'm not like other guys; I'm nervous and my socks are too loose Gender is a state of mind Boys and Girls Learn Differently Schismogenesis
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
After stirring Everything, these nodes rose to the top:
Libber and I go to war
Hydrogen peroxide
Buying lingerie for your girlfriend - the definitive guide
UK Local Elections 2008
Bertolt Brecht
naan
Ferris wheel
Hollandaise VaporMeet
Chinese Dynasties
Sgt. Kenneth Lancaster
Hands
Magic: The Gathering
Super Mario Brothers: A Literary Criticism
New Writeups
The Custodian
Forgotten things in space(place)
DreamingOfGaia
boredom(event)
tentative
July 4, 2008(personal)
Whiskeydaemon
sewing machine(log)
waverider37
Forgotten things in space(poetry)
jessicaj
Days when art is too much to bear(idea)
You've Got Gold
I aborted my peace and tranquility(event)
Simulacron3
Sensing and Perceiving(essay)
StrawberryFrog
Bore(person)
Heitah
The Davy Crockett Weapon System(thing)
Timeshredder
Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull(review)
aneurin
Miles Francis Stapleton Fitzalan Howard, 17th Duke of Norfolk(person)
Bitriot
flashover(thing)
tejasa
Cranberry Cornbread(recipe)
Dreamvirus
Brighton Bombing(event)
This affordable entertainment brought to you by The Everything Development Company